Comparative analysis in education dr ellen boeren course organiser credit rating 20 credits, scqf 11 course description the course aims to provide student with a comprehensive overview of the theories and methodologies used in comparative education research. Grounded theory and the constant comparative method. Shedding light on causal recipes for development research uptake applying qualitative comparative analysis to understand reasons for research uptake vera scholz, amy kirbyshire and nigel simister. Qualitative researchers utilize comparative and casebased methods to develop theory through elaboration or abduction. A purposeful approach to the constant comparative method. It draws on the long tradition of the comparative method in the social sciences but develops this beyond qualitative description. The analysis begins with listing and counting all the combinations of variables observed in the data set, followed by applying the rules of logical inference to determine which descriptive inferences or implications the data supports. Introduction to qualitative comparative analysis qca. Shedding light on causal recipes for development research uptake applying qualitative comparative analysis to understand reasons for research uptake vera scholz, amy kirbyshire and nigel simister may 2016.
Structuring the calibration of qualitative data as sets for qualitative. Introduction to qualitative comparative analysis by wendy olsenpreliminary notes for beginners wendy. For neophyte nurse researchers, many of the data collection. As ragin 2000 demonstrates, the subset relation is central to the analysis of causal complexity. The best way to address the limitations of crosscase analysis is by complementing it with withincase analysis.
Qualitative comparative analysis qca a research method popularized largely through the work of charles ragin ragin,1987,2000,2008 counts among the most in. In grounded theory, the researcher uses multiple stages of collecting, refining, and categorizing the data. View qualitative comparative analysis qca research papers on academia. Qualitative data analysis is an iterative and reflexive process that begins as data are being collected rather. This approach was developed by robert brinkerhoff to assess the impact of organisational interventions, such as training and coaching, though the. May 04, 2016 qualitative comparative analysis qca is a nonprobabilistic method that uses mathematical set theory to study complex phenomena. Thus, although called qualitative comparative analysis, qca is not a qualitative method in the sense of empirical qualitative research. Some of the steps overlap with the traditional quantitative content analysis procedures tesch, 1990, while others are unique to this method. Causes act in combinations several combinations of causal conditions are realted to the same outcome a single causal condition depending on combinations with. A package for qualitative comparative analysis by alrik thiem and adrian dusa. Qca is becoming increasingly popular with social scientists, but none of the existing software alternatives.
Applying constant comparative method with multiple. The success case method scm involves identifying the most and least successful cases in a program and examining them in detail. Jun 20, 2014 we therefore examine an analytical technique, qualitative comparative analysis qca, which has been designed to overcome some of the limitations outlined above. The realm of qca techniquesthat is, the comparative method in the more narrow sense of the termthus has to be distinguished, in particular, from the statistical method, which proceeds on the basis of a large number. Designing research with qualitative comparative analysis.
Tosmana is a tool for qualitative comparative analysis qca. Jan 22, 2014 often, translation or implementation studies use case study methods with small sample sizes. Intermediate level qualitative comparative analysis qca intermediate level qualitative comparative analysis qca 3 tasks for ects credits 3 credits passfail grade. Katy sutcliffe, eppicentre, ucl gj melendez university of warwick helen burchett, lshtm. Qca is designed for use with an intermediate number of cases, typically between 10 and 50.
Learning objectives to discuss some of the theoretical models within which qualitative data can be analysed, and select the most appropriate one for a particular piece of research. To understand the stages involved in qualitative data analysis, and gain some. Qualitative comparative analysis caseoriented understanding. In statistics, qualitative comparative analysis qca is a data analysis technique for determining which logical conclusions a data set supports. Grounded theory was developed by glaser and strauss who believed that theory could emerge through qualitative data analysis. Qualitative comparative analysis better evaluation. This is a more precise version of the common admonition to combine qualitative and quantitative analysis. An introduction to applied data analysis with qualitative.
The qualitative comparative analysis focuses on the detailed study of all the topics that are compared with the base one. Shedding light on causal recipes for development research. A fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis of 14. Qualitative research is conducted in a natural setting and involves a process of building a complex and holistic picture of the phenomenon of interest.
Pdf this chapter discusses different approaches to qualitative comparative analysis qca and their application to comparative public policy. The qca analysts interprets the data qualitatively whilst also looking at causality between the variables. Quantitative comparative analysis department of political. We conduct a general analysis of the use of qualitative comparative analysis qca, and a bibliometric study of the use of qca to analyze the specificities of the.
Comparative education what are the strengths and weaknesses of quantitative and qualitative comparative approaches. This article discusses the method of qualitative comparative analysis qca as an approach that is particularly apt for producing evidence about how to tackle. The development of qualitative comparative analysis qca by charles ragin has given social scientists a formal tool for identifying settheoretic connections based on boolean algebra. In line with ragins own background, qca has been initially employed only by a. Qualitative analysis of content university of texas at. Recent years have witnessed a host of innovations for conducting research with qualitative comparative analysis qca. Learn qualitative comparative analysis qca from erasmus university rotterdam. Virtually it is impossible for comparison not to exist, since it is a major part of human nature. Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a means of analysing the causal contribution of different conditions e.
Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a methodology that enables the analysis of. Trainingcurriculum2 examplesofqualitativeandquantitativedata. As with other methods, the approach should inform all phases of the research process, including sampling or case selection, data collection, analysis, and the interpretation of results. During the last few years especially, the main initial technique, qualitative comparative analysis qca, has been complemented by other related methods and techniques. Next to her field notes or interview transcripts, the qualita. Further, this number of techniques was chosen because they represent all but one of the qualitative analysis techniques. A worked example to explore why some weight management interventions worked better than others. A short introduction to qualitative comparative analysis.
Qualitative data analysis national institute for health. We briefly summarize mixed methods design and factors to consider when designing a mixed methods study that uses qca. Using qualitative comparative analysis qca to study patient. Analyzing international entrepreneurial orientatio. Introduction to qca qualitative comparative analysis some special features of qca ragin 2011. In earnings and capital management in european banks combining multivariate regression and qualitative comparative analysis, pinto and picoto examine the effects of the sovereign debt crisis on the quality of financial reporting in european banks by investigating the existence of earnings and capital management. Shedding light on causal recipes for development research uptake. In the case of qualitative comparative analysis qca, so far these issues have been addressed only partly. Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a casebased method that.
Qualitative comparative analysis qca is both a research approach and a data analysis technique. Miech, edd, prism queri indianapolis laura damschroder, mph, prove queri ann arbor. Depending on the goals of your study, your content analysis may be more flexible or more. Compasss comparative methods for systematic crosscase analysis is a global network which brings together researchers and professionals who share the same interest in theoretic, methodological, and practical advances related to a systematic comparative research approach to the use of configurational logic, the existence of multiple causality. Qualitative comparative analysis a rigorous qualitative. Qca was developed in political science to evaluate case studies with too few cases for standard statistical analysis and where the available data. We conduct a general analysis of the use of qualitative comparative analysis qca, and a bibliometric study of the use of qca to analyze the specificities of the research publications that apply this methodology. Qca starts with the documentation of the different configurations of conditions associated with each case of an observed outcome. Qualitative comparative analysis using fuzzy sets fsqca. The fsqca is a form of succession of qualitative comparative analysis qca that was used in social science based on the boolean method that used classical set theory 27. After this, we will propose a list of criteria for a good qca analysis. The purpose is to show the strength of using cca to maintain the emic perspective and how theoretical frameworks can maintain the etic perspective throughout the analysis. At the same time, qca is capable of pinpointing decisive crosscase patterns, the usual domain of quantitative analysis. Using qualitative comparative analysis qca to study.
A qualitative comparative analysis on factors affecting. Qualitative comparative analysis with r springerlink. Qualitative comparative analysis qca and related techniques applied social research methods ragin, charles c. We discuss this tools main tenets, advantages, and disadvantages.
Its interest does not lie in the disaggregation of cases into analytically separate variables and the identification of a single cause, but. The constant comparative analysis method outside of grounded theory abstract this commentary addresses the gap in the literature regarding discussion of the legitimate use of constant comparative analysis method cca outside of grounded theory. Correlationbased methods of scientific enquiry, however, use linear algebra and are unsuited to analyzing set relations. Pdf qualitative comparative analysis as an evaluation tool. If youre looking for a free download links of qualitative data analysis. Glaser university of california medical center, san francisco research into social problems, problems of deviation, of control and of crisis, and the likethe general subject matter to which social problems is devotedis still mainly feasible through methods which yield. Qualitative comparative analysis a rigorous qualitative method. What is qualitative comparative analysis qca charles c. By contrast, a study based upon a qualitative process of inquiry has the goal of understanding a social or human problem from multiple perspectives. Scott, md abstract patientcare practices often lag behind currentscienti. Qualitative comparative analysis qca research papers. Attendance at least at the 90% of the course hours, participation inclass activities, doing necessary reading andor other work prior to, and after, class. Handouton qualitative andquantitativemethodsanddatasession4evidenceinformedpolicymaking.
If possible, it is good to balance crosscase and withincase analysis in social research. Qca is a method that bridges qualitative and quantitative analysis. The constant comparative analysis method outside of grounded. The contributions of qualitative comparative analysis qca. Quantitative and qualitative comparative analysis in business. Article qualitative comparative analysis as an evaluation tool. Qualitative comparative analysis qca offers a new, systematic way of studying configurations of cases. Ebn notebook data analysis in qualitative research unquestionably, data analysis is the most complex and mysteri ous of all of the phases of a qualitative project, and the one that receives the least thoughtful discussion in the literature. Qualitative comparative analysis qca and related techniques. Please read the points below before you start the course. Quantitative comparative analysis, in edward elgar encyclopedia of global environmental politics and governance, edited by philipp pattberg and fariborz zelli.
Introduction to qualitative comparative analysis qca dr. Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a new analytic technique that uses boolean algebra to implement principles of comparison used by scholars engaged in the qualitative study of macro social phenomena. Qualitative comparative analysis qca as an approach. A comparative analysis of qualitative and quantitative research methods and a justification for use of mixed methods in social research. Rather, it should be seen as a middle way that combines certain features of the qualitative approach case orientation, interest in complexity with those. Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a social science research method that applies a systematic comparison to case study research. The motivation of this paper is to introduce is researchers to qualitative comparative analysis qca as a useful data analysis method that has the potential to explain diverse interactions of factors associated similar outcomes in. We then set out the questions motivating the symposium and briefly introduce the con. While general introductions and users guides for qca software packages are available, prospective users find little guidance as to how the method works in applied data analysis. Methodological approaches that systematize findings from these types of studies are needed to improve rigor and advance the field. Pdf qualitative comparative analysis qca as an approach to. Method the method of fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis fsqca is employed to investigate factors affecting the deployment of electric vehicles across the countries. Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a method and analytical approach that can advance implementation science. A short introduction to qualitative comparative analysis stefan verweij department of public administration erasmus university rotterdam.
The constant comparative analysis method outside of. Stefan verweij department of spatial planning and environment faculty of spatial sciences university of groningen s. Welcome to this massive open online course mooc about qualitative comparative analysis qca. It can help explain why change happens in some cases but not others. Locate qca as an approach and grasp its key epistemological foundations. Abstract we present qca, a package for performing qualitative comparative analysis qca. Qca is used in comparative research and when using casestudy research methods. Organisational factors for corporate social responsibility implementation in sport federations. Qualitative comparative analysis and implementation research. International journal of social research methodology, 162, 165166. Pdf qualitative comparative analysis qca is gaining ground in evaluation circles, but the number of applications is still limited. More informations about qca can be found on the website of charles. Qualitative comparative analysis qca as an approach dirkbergschlosser giseledemeur benoitrihoux charlesc.
You are probably familiar with the basic differences between qualitative and quantitative research methods, and their different applications in dealing with research questions posed in health care research. Majersik, md, lingling zhang, ma, annette sandretto, msn, phillip a. Most aspects of qca require familiarity with cases, which in turn demands indepth knowledge. Pdf qualitative comparative analysis qca and related. Quantitative and qualitative comparative approaches. Qualitative data analysis is an iterative and reflexive process that begins as data are being collected rather than after data collection has ceased stake 1995. Qualitative comparative analysis using fuzzy sets fsqca forthcoming in benoit rihoux and charles ragin editors, configurational comparative analysis, sage publications, 2007 charles c. Applying constant comparative method with multiple investigators and intercoder reliability abstract building on practice, action research, and theory, the purpose of this paper is to present a 10step method for applying the constant comparative method ccm of grounded theory when multiple researchers perform data analysis and meaning making.
Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a methodology that enables the analysis of multiple cases in complex situations. Qualitative comparative analysis a rigorous qualitative method for assessing impact qca is a case based method which allows evaluators to identify different combinations of factors that are critical to a given outcome, in a given context. Pdf a comparative analysis of qualitative and quantitative. The software can be used for csqca crispset qualitative comparative analysis and mvqca multivalue qca calculations.
Qualitative comparative analysis qca is a powerful approach for studying pcmhs and other health services interventions thygeson, solberg, asche, et al. Qualitative comparative analysis in political scie. A methods sourcebook pdf, epub, docx and torrent then this site is not for you. While fuzzy sets solve the problem of trying to forcefit cases into one of two categories membership versus nonmembership in a set or into one of three or four categories 1 mvqca, they are not well suited for conventional truth table analysis. Using qualitative comparative analysis to understand and. American journal of evaluation qualitative comparative the.
1151 1547 515 1477 1094 1262 369 568 487 1380 1031 174 112 660 526 403 1020 143 655 772 706 884 156 1393 825 984 482 1341 39 1212 1322 593 1107 170 954